Home Brew Blog - Brewer's Friend - Part 31
Brew your best beer EVER. Start your Free Trial of Brewer's Friend today! Sign Up ×

Pick the Correct Size Secondary Fermenter

Saturday, November 15th, 2008

Oxygen is the enemy of beer after fermentation. The main cause of oxidation in beer is exposure to oxygen when racking or bottling. Another culprit is the head space in the secondary fermenter. Make sure to use the smallest size secondary fermenter possible as not to expose the beer to oxygen in the head space. For example a typical 5 gallon batch should use a 6.5 gallon carboy or bucket as the primary fermenter, then a 5 gallon carboy as the secondary. There will be almost no head space in the secondary if done correctly.

Rules of thumb:

  • Head space is needed in the primary, since there will be a lot of foam during the krausen phase of fermentation. Oxygen in the head space is not an issue during primary fermentation because it will be replaced by CO2 when fermentation kicks off and any dissolved oxygen will be utilized by the yeast. Some will also be pushed out through the air lock with the escaping CO2.
  • Head space is bad in the secondary. Since the beer is fermenting slowly, it will take longer to push oxygen in the head space out through the air lock. This means most of the oxygen in the head space is getting into the beer and causing harmful effects.

Why is oxygen harmful in the secondary?

Oxygen (O2) is a reactive molecule. During primary fermentation the yeast use oxygen quickly as part of the metabolic reaction that produces alcohol. Inside the secondary the yeast metabolism has settled down greatly. This leaves any newly introduced oxygen free to interact with larger desirable molecules responsible for flavor and bittering. When the oxygen hits these molecules it splits them apart making for undesirable byproducts in the beer. Wet paper bag or cardboard taste is generally the telling sign of oxidized beer.

Lagering At Home Video

Monday, November 3rd, 2008

This video shows you what an in home lagering setup looks like. Also includes a look at corny kegs and the temperature controller needed for fermentation of a lager.

The beer being fermented is a Munich Helles!

Money Saving Tips – Hops Utilization Factor

Sunday, November 2nd, 2008

Minimizing costs and maximizing beer is a wonderful thing to put into practice. This post discusses the idea of getting more bittering potential from hops. With hops going for $32/pound this is worth paying attention to.

Alpha acids in hops are isomerized into bitter flavors during the boil.  The utilization factor is a number that expresses how easily and completely this process takes place.  Higher utilization translates into a higher amount of international bittering units (IBUs). The utilization factor decreases as the boil gravity increases. This means the more sugary your wort is, the less bittering you will get per ounce of hops.   Therefore by lowering the gravity of the boil it is possible to stretch hops bittering quality.

This tip really only applies to extract brewers who are able to add fermentable sugars in a more flexible manner than all-grain brewers who need a full wort boil. All grain brewers do not suffer from such setbacks in hops utilization because their wort boil gravity is essentially what the original gravity of the recipe is. Most extract books say to add all the dry/liquid malt extract at the start of the boil to 3 gallons of water, then dilute to five gallons afterwards. This hurts the hops bittering potential!

The basic procedure to get your wort gravity down is to use half of your extract for the entire boil at the time the bittering hops are added.  With 15 minutes to go (usually after 45 minutes of boiling), add the rest of the extract to bring up the gravity to where the recipe calls for. This will sanitize the extract and sufficiently integrate it into the wort before cooling.

You can see this in action by playing with this website’s IBU calculator.

Let’s consider an example: a simple lager with 2 oz of Hallertauer hops, Alpha Acid rating of 3.9, boiled for 60 minutes, no other hops additions.

In the case of an extract batch with an original gravity of 1.055 for a 5 gallon batch, but only boiling 3 gallons, we get 18.53 IBU’s.

If we tell the calculator the boil gravity was only 1.028 (half the sugars), we get an IBU rating of 27!  For calculation purposes we get close to what we would see with a full wort boil (enter 5 gallons for boil size and 1.055 for gravity) and it comes out to around 25.

A 38% increase in hops bittering potential is pretty good. That translates into a 38% savings in the cost of our bittering hops. It also means more bitter beer which a lot of home brewers really like – including the author!

Note: this practice may throw off the style of beer your batch fits into by boosting bitterness beyond where it needs to be. It will also allow you to make your next IPA much more bitter for the money.  IPAs are particularly expensive to make these days because they call for 2x-3x hops, and about half of that is for bittering.

Halloween brew

Monday, October 27th, 2008

This is pretty spooky looking. Shine a flashlight through all the gunk that builds up on the inside of the carboy when fermenting a dark or high gravity beer!

Halloween brew

Whoo-hahahaah!

If you don’t wash it out after racking I bet it gets even spookier!

Speaking of spooky, I’ve been thinking about some ingredients people used in the past, like dandelion for bittering. That sounds like a witch’s brew. I could be wrong but that *might* be the reason why they don’t make it in today’s time.

I’m going to try a cranberry mead in a week, that should be more in line with my personal taste. I’ll let you know how it goes!

Homebrewing for Dummies – by Marty Nachel

Saturday, October 25th, 2008

Homebrewing for Dummies – by Marty Nachel
A Reference for the Rest of Us!

Covers everything from A-Z in brewing. A good text if you only had one book to buy and were a raw beginner. Some of the specialty chapters are worth checking too and go way beyond a what you might expect from a watered down ‘dummies’ book. The chapters on the ingredients in beer, needed equipment, extract brewing, bottling and kegging are good. The emphasis on secondary fermentation is good. I found the all-grain section a little oversimplified, enough information to get started but not enough to get past the basics. A good chunk of the book (100 pages out of about 400) is recipes, with extract and all grain variations on almost every style of beer. Then the book gets interesting and goes into cider and meads, a topic you rarely see. Then it gets even more interesting with a chapter on gluten free brewing (making beer without standard barley or wheat). Also covers green practices in brewing and organic ingredients, judging beer, and beer troubleshooting.

Topics unique to the book:

  • Emphasis on secondary fermentation
  • Basic intro to all grain brewing
  • First Wort Hopping (covered in chapter 12 on all grain brewing)
  • Brewing cider at home
  • Brewing mead and its sub categories – traditional, melomel (fruit), and others (braggot, metheglin) in dry or sweet variations.
  • Brewing green and using organic ingredients
  • Gluten free brewing
  • Home brew competitions and beer tasting
  • Beer quality troubleshooting

Amarillo and Brown Sugar IPA, 2008

Sunday, October 12th, 2008

Amarillo hops impart a citrus grapefruit note to the aroma and flavor of the beer they are used in. This IPA recipe highlights the Amarillo hops and creates an IPA that is fairly mellow compared to some of the stronger IPAs.

This recipe is quite complex and deviates a bit from standard recipes. Using 6 pounds of DME, and the brown sugar later, I decided to dilute the primary to 6.5 gallons. Otherwise the beer would have been 6%+ alcohol by volume. This way there is more of it, but lugging the carboy around when it is full is harder.

After three days I added brown sugar directly to the primary fermenter. The sugar was dissolved in near boiling water and cooled before being added. This boosted the SG and darkened the beer slightly. It did not make the beer sweet since it is all eaten by the yeast. Adding sugar during primary fermentation is a trick to boost gravity. The yeast took off when I added the sugar. A blowoff tube was definitely needed.

In the secondary I dry hopped with more Amarillo. The results were awesome, this is one of the best beers I have crafted. Next time I will try a different type of yeast (this is the only thing I would dare change).

Target Volume (Gallons) 6.5      
Total Cost $39.51
 
   
Yield (ounces) 800      
Cost per 12 oz bottle $0.59      
Boil Time 60 min    
         
GRAINS  Pounds  Points/Gal  Total Points  Cost 
Extra Light DME 6 46 276 $18.00
Steep – 30 min at 150 F         
German Melanoidin 30L 1.5 15 22.5 $1.79
         
         
Light Brown Sugar – organic 0.5 46 23 $1.00
         
         
         
HOPS  Ounces  Alpha Acids Boil Time (min)  Cost 
Magnum 1 14.60% 60 $3.00
Cascade 0.5 6.00% 30 $2.12
Cascade 0.5 6.00% 15  
Amarillo 1 8.40% 15 $4.00
Amarillo 1   Dry, Secondary  
         

 
       
YEAST  White Labs California Ale     Cost 
Attenuation Low 73%     $6.95
Attenuation High 80%      
Optimum Temp 68-73 F      
Flocculation Medium      
Starter No      
         
STATS         
Expected Original Gravity 1.049       
Expected Final Gravity Theoretical 1.01 – 1.013      
Expected Final Gravity Actual 1.01 – 1.013      
IBUs 39.13       
Apparent Attenuation 79.59% AA = 1 – FG / OG    
Alcohol By Volume – Theoretical 5.18%      
Alcohol By Volume – Potential 5.12%      
         
BREWING:  Squeezed out hops bags medium      
  ½ tbs Irish Moss at start of boil     $0.10
         
Water Source Wort Pure water filter – 3 gallon boil      
Water Source Dilution Pure water filter      
         
         
DATES  Date SG Cum. Days Notes
Brewed 07/27/08 1.049 0  Added ½ lb of brown sugar 3 days later (boosts SG by 0.005). definitely needed blowoff tube
Racked 08/05/08 1.015 9 Racked into 7gal bucket w/spigot. Nice clean bitter taste, can’t taste sugar, light body, no gelatin
Bottled (SG pre bottling) 08/15/08 1.010  19 bitter ‘hit’ has dropped off a lot, lighter flavor than expected
   
 
  Used half of the oxygen protector caps to see if there is a difference.
OK TO DRINK BY (60 days): 09/25/08       
         
BOTTLING         
Priming Method 5 oz Corn Syrup     $0.30
Caps, cleaners, etc
 
    $2.25
         
Container  Capacity  Qty  Total Volume   
Bottle 12 34 408  
Lagunitas 22 5 110  
Half Liter (Deutsch) 17 13 221  
Jug 64 1 64  
         
    Total Bottled:  803   
         
         
TASTING         
  08/20/08 24   A bit green but ready to drink, plenty of fizz and head.
  10/01/08 66   Grapefruit notes from the amarillo hops, nice balance
  10/15/08 80   I’m actually glad I diluted this because it is lighter drinking and I got more of it! I do notice a difference from the oxycaps.
         
         

Orange American Hefeweizen II, 2008

Sunday, October 5th, 2008

After brewing my first orange hefeweizen about two months ago I wanted to fine tune the recipe.
This time I used sterling hops instead of cascade to reduce the biterness. Some people mentioned it was pretty bitter (not a bad thing for me). I had originally set out to replicate the Eugene City Brewery’s Honey Orange Wheat, I thought that would be the next logical step. I also used half the amount of sweet orange peel. The results are closer, but this beer still has way too much flavor. To replicate ECB’s beer, I would need to cut the hops in half again, and probably cut the orange in half too.

One thing I have noticed about both times using coriander, after about 75 days the flavor really starts to settle down. I think these beers were better when they were the freshest. It could also have been oxygen taint. That said, this beer is ready to drink in about 4 weeks!

I brought a growler jug (64 oz) to a party and it was gone in 45 minutes with people asking for more. It is a beer that non beer drinkers can try a little of and enjoy.

Target Volume (Gallons) 5      
Total Cost $38.32
 
   
Yield (ounces) 620      
Cost per 12 oz bottle $0.74      
Boil Time 60 min    
         
GRAINS  Pounds  Points/Gal  Total Points  Cost 
Extra Light DME 60/40 wheat 6 46 276 $18.00
Honey – Wild Flowers, Oregon 1 35 35 $4.32
Steep – 30 min at 150 F         
Honey Malt, Domestic 0.5 28 14 $0.80
         
Sweet Orange Peels – 1/2oz (10 minutes)       $1.00
Coriander – 1 oz crushed, (10 minutes)       $1.00
         
HOPS  Ounces  Alpha Acids Boil Time (min)  Cost 
Sterling/Saaz 1 5.00% 60 $4.00
Sterling/Saaz 1 5.00% 10  
         

 
       
YEAST  White Labs American Hefeweizen Ale     Cost 
Attenuation Low 70%     $6.95
Attenuation High 75%      
Optimum Temp 65-68F      
Flocculation Low      
         
Starter No      
         
STATS         
Expected Original Gravity 1.065       
Expected Final Gravity Theoretical 1.016 – 1.02      
Expected Final Gravity Actual 1.014 – 1.017      
IBUs 15.71      
Apparent Attenuation 75.44% AA = 1 – FG / OG    
Alcohol By Volume – Theoretical 6.69%      
Alcohol By Volume – Potential 5.64%      
         
BREWING:  Squeezed out hops bags medium      
  ½ tbs Irish Moss at start of boil     $0.10
  Used wort chiller for 1st time!       
Water Source Wort Filtered water – 3 gallons      
Water Source Dilution Filtered water      
         
DATES  Date SG Cum. Days Notes
Brewed 07/15/08 1.057 0   
Racked 07/22/08 1.028 7 Lost some beer due to jostling carboy, got a lot of yeast uptake
Bottled (SG pre bottling) 08/06/08 1.014  22 Late bottling due to continued airlock activity
OK TO DRINK BY (40 days): 08/24/08 
 
   
OK TO DRINK BY (50 days): 09/03/08       
         
BOTTLING         
Priming Method 6 oz Corn Sugar     $0.40
Caps, cleaners, etc
 
    $1.75
         
Container  Capacity  Qty  Total Volume   
Lagunitas 22 12 264  
Half Liter (Deutsch) 17 0 0  
Bottle 12 19 228  
Mini-keg 169 0 0  
Jug 64 2 128  
    Total Bottled:  620   
         
         
TASTING         
  08/12/08 28 Very fragrant of oranges, not bitter at all, but starting to develop some body after early bottles.  
  08/28/08 44 Citrus and slight orange flavor still present, very soft biterness. Holds head.
  09/14/08 54 Citrus and slight orange flavor still present, very soft biterness. Holds head.
         
         

German Kolsh Ale, 2008

Saturday, October 4th, 2008

White labs offers a Klösh yeast for making a German ale. It is not as robust as a lager, this beer is light and a bit sweet. It’s a respectable easy drinking beer. If you want to lighten it up even more (like Budweiser or Coors), try substituting a pound of rice solids in place of a pound of DME. For me, it is so light there is no need to take it further. This is a great beer to brew for your first time. It is very simple with only one hop addition at the beginning.

Target Volume (Gallons) 5      
Total Cost $29.45
 
   
Yield (ounces) 630      
Cost per 12 oz bottle $0.56      
Boil Time 60 min    
         
GRAINS  Pounds  Points/Gal  Total Points  Cost 
Light DME 5 46 230 $15.00
Steep – 30 min at 150 F         
German Pilsner Malt 0.5 28 14 $1.00
         
         
HOPS  Ounces  Alpha Acids Boil Time (min)  Cost 
Domestic Hallertau 2 3.90% 60 $4.25
         
         

 
       
YEAST  White Labs German Ale Kölsh Yeast     Cost 
Attenuation Low 72%     $6.65
Attenuation High 78%      
Optimum Temp 65-69 F      
Flocculation Medium      
         
Starter No      
         
STATS         
Expected Original Gravity 1.049       
Expected Final Gravity Theoretical 1.011 – 1.014      
Expected Final Gravity Actual 1.01 – 1.012      
IBUs 21.85       
Apparent Attenuation 75.00% AA = 1 – FG / OG    
Alcohol By Volume – Theoretical 4.96%      
Alcohol By Volume – Potential 4.33%      
         
BREWING:  Squeezed out hops bags medium      
  ½ tbs Irish Moss at start of boil     $0.10
         
Water Source Wort Pure water filter – 3 gallon boil      
Water Source Dilution Pure water filter      
At racking, gelatin as a clarifier       $0.20
         
DATES  Date SG Cum. Days Notes
Brewed 06/13/08 1.044 0   
Racked 06/23/08 1.012 10 Added ½ tsp gelatin, lighter in color, tastes bready excellent, no syrupy flavor
Bottled (SG pre bottling) 07/01/08 1.011  18 Wow that takes awesome, crisp, not carmely at all, light mild bitter finish
   
 
   
OK TO DRINK BY (60 days): 08/12/08       
         
BOTTLING         
Priming Method 5 oz Corn Syrup (1 cup)     $0.50
Caps, cleaners, etc
 
    $1.75
         
Container  Capacity  Qty  Total Volume   
Bottle 12 11 132  
Corny Keg        
         
         
         
    Total Bottled:  132   
         
         
TASTING         
  07/04/08 21 Put it on tap, could not resist to try, tastes weak and sweet, need to wait more  
  07/20/08 37 This is getting less sweet, very clear and light colored.  
  08/08/08 56 Everybody likes this beer, it is light flavored, a bit sweet, very refreshing.  
  08/15/08 63 Refreshing crisp and light, beer is improving with age.  
  09/15/08 84 Sweetness has let up a lot, very refreshing and thirst quenching.  

The Homebewer’s Answer Book – By Ashton Lewis

Saturday, September 27th, 2008

The Homebewer’s Answer Book – By Ashton Lewis
Solutions to Every Problem, Answers to Every Question

Pickup this book after you have been brewing for several months to fill in some gaps in your knowledge and open the door to new ideas. The book is compact in size but thick. It is not suitable to read for a raw beginner. It gets into a lot of complicated and advanced areas. I would get it in the first year and refer back to it over the course of your progression from beginner to master. Mainly the book focuses on how to perfect your brewing processes. Every home brewer can get a lot out of this book.

Topics unique to this book:

  • Sanitization techniques
  • Answers about use of materials in brewing, such as CPVC vs copper pipes, stainless steel vs aluminum, etc
  • Dry hopping vs using a hopback
  • Brewing with different levels of water hardness
  • Reusing yeast and re-pitching rates, yeast considerations for lager beers
  • All grain techniques, tradeoffs with different mash schedules, and the basic chemistry involved
  • Putting beer on tap using nitrogen (nitro)
  • Troubleshooting to improve head stability, chill haze, DMS, etc.
  • Troubleshooting with bad batches

When to use a blowoff tube

Sunday, September 21st, 2008

For dark beers or beers with a specific gravity greater than 1.060, in my experience, a blow off tube is need to keep from having an overflowing mess.

Here is a picture of a porter that is only 24 hours into fermentation. You can see the amount of gunk on the glass in the head space got up to the airlock. I pitched two cups of slurry from a previous batch of English Pub Bitter and the fermentation took off like a rocket. In five hours the tube was making a tapping noise every couple seconds as it bubbled. The strain is White Labs British Ale Yeast.

Blowoff tube