Need an Opinion on A Sierra Nevada Clone--Virtual Tasting.

add gypsum
Adding gypsum generally increases the perception of bitterness, in my experience. When I want a hoppy beer like a pale or IPA and some UK pub styles, I use more gypsum than CaCl. When I want a malty beer like German lager or Brown Ale, it's the other way around.
 
An BTW gypsum and campden is all I am currently adding. Still getting acquainted with water chemistry calculator and water chem in general
yes so the issue is your hardness, you will need some acid of some kind, i cant say how much, each amout is different for each recipe, grain and water
 
with all neutral water my recipe will taste good, adding gypsum without lowering the alkalinity will be too bitter, its really a hard beer to brew and taste like the original
you need to put your grain bill in and adjust your ph then see about adjusting the alkilinity
you can dilute with distilled then build up with salts
with you posting only your water profile probably teaspoon of gypsum and teaspoon of lactic acid and see what that does
do you know how to use the water calculator software?
 
you need to put your grain bill in and adjust your ph then see about adjusting the alkilinity
you can dilute with distilled then build up with salts
with you posting only your water profile probably teaspoon of gypsum and teaspoon of lactic acid and see what that does
do you know how to use the water calculator software?
I am learning. :). I have a PH meter but have not ventured into using it yet. Just getting the process more predictable has been consuming.
 
Thanks. I will play around with the calculator. Not sure how to impact the alkalinity with phosphoric acid in the software.
You would probably be fine with acidulated malt in the grain bill (can also use small amount of citric or phosphoric) and acidifying sparge water with citric or phosporic. Your water PH is probably pretty high so adjusting sparge water can do you a lot of good not only for flavor but for mash and sparge efficiency.
 
You would probably be fine with acidulated malt in the grain bill (can also use small amount of citric or phosphoric) and acidifying sparge water with citric or phosporic. Your water PH is probably pretty high so adjusting sparge water can do you a lot of good not only for flavor but for mash and sparge efficiency.
PH as measured by Ward was 7.9. So maybe 3 ish % of acidulated malt in the grain bill? Then what the water calculator suggests for the phosphoric?
 
read this for how it was developed, it has changed today
https://sierranevada.com/blog/our-beer/pale-ale-homebrew-recipe

1.0-Homebrewed-Recipe.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: J A
PH as measured by Ward was 7.9. So maybe 3 ish % of acidulated malt in the grain bill? Then what the water calculator suggests for the phosphoric?
I use the water chemistry calculator for mash liquor additions and sparge water acidification and the recipe calculator will adjust your mash pH according to the ingredients you use so it's easy to know exactly how much acidulated to use. For most 10 gallon recipes I end up with anywhere between 6 and 12 ounces if I recall.
Sometimes I forget to calculate sparge water addition and just wing it by adding a milliliter at a time or even a few drops at a time until it's the right pH. - 5.4 is recommended.
 
I just found the recipe on the SN site.
The 5 gal home brew recipe at the SN site has changed over the decades (see the Internet Archives"way back machine"). There was a time when Magnum + Perle was used for bittering.
 
Refresh my memory.

Are you using municipal tap water?

Is the water being softened?

If so, are you treating it with campden to eliminate the chlorine?

Is the water good, does it have any odors, and does it taste good?
 
Sorry, just saw above that you are using campden, curious on the other questions though
 
Refresh my memory.

Are you using municipal tap water?

Is the water being softened?

If so, are you treating it with campden to eliminate the chlorine?

Is the water good, does it have any odors, and does it taste good?
Municipal Tap -Yes
Water Softener - No using the tap that is prior to the softener.
Campden - Yep
Water quality - No odors or 'offensive" tastes
 
Municipal Tap -Yes
Water Softener - No using the tap that is prior to the softener.
Campden - Yep
Water quality - No odors or 'offensive" tastes
Great, do you drink your tap water?
 
OK. Gang...here you go. My first attempt at using the recipe builder/water chem. Something is not right as it is looking for 130ml of phosphoric acid. Otherwise, feels like things are headed in the right direction. Nod to J A and Ozarks Mountain Brewery for the example to work from.

https://www.brewersfriend.com/homebrew/recipe/edit/1618918
 
The pH of your source water is irrelevant. If has little buffering power - meaning small amounts of acid or base will move the pH easily.

Much more important is your mash pH.
 

Back
Top