Nosybear brought up a point that is very relevant to this portion of the forum. I'm not trying to step on anyone's toes because lots of us do it including me. Ask for feedback on recipes that are not complete. There are so many variables in brewing that without the right info it is impossible to give a good response. There are lots of reasons to discuss recipes of your own or one you found and want to try so for good feedback we need to put volumes of all ingredients including water or batch size. Maybe even your type of brewing. If it can affect the outcome of a recipe it needs to be included. Ok I will step down off the box now. Thanks, and happy brewing!!!