Hammer1 said:
Like I said there are a lot of valid arguments for starters, over my years of homebrewing I have found no advantage to making them. And I have made plenty. If you feel the need to over pitch just spend the extra five bucks for a second smack pack or vial. If you add up the cost of stir plates, flasks, stir bars, DME and your time. You could of just purchased a bunch of yeast.
I was with Hammer1 for a long time in my earlier brewing days.
I was also in the camp that it didn't matter if you pitched dry.
I liked my beer and so did my friends.
When I started to enter competitions and have my beers judged, the feedback I got made me reconsider many parts of my brewing process.
I started looking at the little things. Yeast pitch rate, pitching temperature, cell count pitched, temperature control for fermentation's, aeration,etc.
I started to notice differences and although my beers have got better and even won awards, I'm still always looking to improve.
I have had the opportunity to meet and discuss some yeast issues with Chris White, Jamil Zainasheff and Keith Lemke. All have expressed to me the importance of proper fermentation's as the number 1 most important part of brewing.
So, for what it's worth, I think starters and cell count are extremely important.
Brian