What am I doing Wrong?

[Over The Cliff Brewing]

My methods are the same. I think it is the adjustment of the efficiency in recipe builder that I need to do. Also, going back through my brews, the efficiency started to go down when I bought the new kettle that is taller but not as wide and 5.5 gallon capacity vs 5 gal capacity of the old kettle. Not sure if this has an impact but that is the only change I've made in my BIAB process.

 

[Zambi]

That could make a change to your boil off amounts.
Narrower should boil off a little less resulting in higher volume with same amount of grains and thus lower OG.
Maybe