My May Mild

Ward Chillington

Well-Known Member
Trial Member
Established Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2018
Messages
3,009
Reaction score
5,699
Points
113
So I'm putting together my recipe outline and steps for a Dark Mild and I have run into a bit of a headscratch that I want to solicit your help with as to getting to the target 5.5 gallon batch.

The grainbill is about 7.1 pounds and with my normal process using 1.5 and 2 quarts per pound respectively for my strike and sparge water, after boil off and kettle loss, I'm about 2 gallons shy of the 5.5 target. I know i could just dump in water to make up the delta but that's gonna screw with my gravity.

I've never brewed a small beer so what's the trick?
 
What is the Fg target? I do plenty batches that are only 7-8 lbs of grain. I just mash at about 3 gallons and top up before the boil.
Of course the mash gravity is much higher than you want, to but after the top up, it's usually close
 
So I'm putting together my recipe outline and steps for a Dark Mild and I have run into a bit of a headscratch that I want to solicit your help with as to getting to the target 5.5 gallon batch.

The grainbill is about 7.1 pounds and with my normal process using 1.5 and 2 quarts per pound respectively for my strike and sparge water, after boil off and kettle loss, I'm about 2 gallons shy of the 5.5 target. I know i could just dump in water to make up the delta but that's gonna screw with my gravity.

I've never brewed a small beer so what's the trick?
you use the same water amounts as a 5% but less grain, that's it, you do want more flavor to make up for the extra water but not extra fermentables
 
What is the Fg target? I do plenty batches that are only 7-8 lbs of grain. I just mash at about 3 gallons and top up before the boil.
Of course the mash gravity is much higher than you want, to but after the top up, it's usually close

No FG given in the recipe but the OG is 1037 but I have not put this grain bill into the recipe builder yet so....figure a tad below your typical stout starting in the 40s and getting into the mid teens. It's a Drew Beechum recipe

https://www.experimentalbrew.com/recipes/cdjk-mild

you use the same water amounts as a 5% but less grain, that's it, you do want more flavor to make up for the extra water but not extra fermentables

I figure I'll play with the OG and my sweet wort ...tomorrow oughta be fun!
 
Last edited:
sorry,
No FG given in the recipe but the OG is 1037 but I have not put this grain bill into the recipe builder yet so....figure a tad below your typical stout starting in the 40s and getting into the mid teens. It's a Drew Breachem recipe
sorry that is what I meant. that is about what I would expect. your gravity might be in the 50s or 60s durring the mash depending on how much water you use. but after topping it up, it should be alright. you can mash with the full volume too, but I find that the super thin grist doesnt work as well. maybe its just in my head, lol.
 
Do what you'd do for a bigger beer: For 5.5 gallons into the fermenter, you need about 6 to 6-1/4 gallons for mash and about 1-1/2 gallons for sparge. That assumes 1/2 qt per lb grain absorption and just a bit over a gallon boil off.
 
Do what you'd do for a bigger beer: For 5.5 gallons into the fermenter, you need about 6 to 6-1/4 gallons for mash and about 1-1/2 gallons for sparge. That assumes 1/2 qt per lb grain absorption and just a bit over a gallon boil off.

Hey Don @Donoroto, could you point me to or pm me an actual example of this as in the specific volumes of strike and sparge water for a high gravity batch?

That's one of the next batches I want to brew, something with a OG in the 1070 or 1080 range. My assumption is that my normal 1.5 mash and 2 qt sparge grain bill to water ratios would just make a larger batch of a 5% beer. Anyone else with some high gravity experience tips please, chime in! Tia!
 
I'm traveling at the moment so a short answer first.

Brew with the max water and grain first, to get as much sugar out of the grain as possible, then sparge to get your volume. Add sugars (invert syrup, sucrose, honey, lme or dme) to get the desired OG, then boil.

my system can handle almost 14 pounds of green with 6 1/4 gallons in the pot. That will bring me into the low 60s. Then I will Sparge with one and a half to 2 gallons to get my 6 1/2 gallon pre-boil value. If I add a pound of dry malt extract that brings it up another 10 points or so, then I boil down to my 5 1/2 gallon target.

You can also add the DME after boiling so you can really be pretty precise on your original gravity.

You can add more than a pound to get up even higher if that's what you're aiming for. Just remember to pitch extra yeast in any batch that's over 60.

I'm doing this on my phone, so it's not easy to find a recipe that does this, but if you go and search recipes and just set the OG and style you'll find plenty of examples.
 
I always work backwards from the pre boil volume.
For example, if your pre boil volume is 6.5 gallons, add the amount of absorption to that. So for 10# of grain, your grain will absorb about a gallon of water, so start with 7.5 gallons.
Divide that into strike and sparge in any ratios you prefer and in the end you'll end up with your pre boil amount.
You may have losses to you mash tun, so you can adjust slightly, but that'll get you very close.
 
Cool, thanks Brian! I'll check this thread again when I start working on that high gravity batch. I'm sure I'll have questions!
 

Defer( function () { $(document).ready(function() { if ( ! document.cookie.match(/^(.*;)?\s*bf_adfpv_v1\s*=\s*[^;]+(.*)?$/) ) { var date = new Date(); var now = new Date(); date.setTime(date.getTime()+(10*365*24*60*60*1000)); var expires = "; expires="+date.toGMTString(); document.cookie = "bf_adfpv_v1="+now.toGMTString()+expires+"; path=/"; } else { // Initialize AdSense (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []); // Affiliate ad override configuration from PHP var affiliateOverrides = {"top-leaderboard-ad":{"total_percentage":25,"options":[{"name":"House Ad","weight":1,"href":"\/homebrew\/signup","img":"\/homebrew\/images\/houseads_20211207\/take10_signup\/webp\/810X100.webp","width":810,"height":100}]},"inline-unit-ad":{"total_percentage":25,"options":[{"name":"House Ad","weight":1,"href":"\/homebrew\/signup","img":"\/homebrew\/images\/houseads_20211207\/take10_signup\/webp\/810X100.webp","width":810,"height":100}]},"sidebar-block-1-ad":{"total_percentage":25,"options":[{"name":"House Ad","weight":1,"href":"\/homebrew\/signup","img":"\/homebrew\/images\/houseads_20211207\/take10_signup\/webp\/300x250.webp","width":300,"height":250}]}}; // Process each potential ad override if (affiliateOverrides && Object.keys(affiliateOverrides).length > 0) { Object.keys(affiliateOverrides).forEach(function(adSlotId) { var override = affiliateOverrides[adSlotId]; var adElement = document.getElementById(adSlotId); // Check if ad exists and should be replaced based on total percentage if (adElement && override.options && override.options.length > 0 && (Math.random() * 100 < override.total_percentage)) { // Choose an option based on weights var option = chooseWeightedOption(override.options); // Build affiliate ad HTML var style = option.style || ''; if (option.width && option.height) { style += (style ? '; ' : '') + 'max-width:100%;'; } var attributes = ''; if (option.target) attributes += ' target="' + option.target + '"'; if (option.rel) attributes += ' rel="' + option.rel + '"'; var affiliateAdHtml = '
' + '' + '' + '
'; // Replace the AdSense container with affiliate ad $(adElement).closest('ins.adsbygoogle').replaceWith(affiliateAdHtml); } }); } // Helper function to select a weighted random option function chooseWeightedOption(options) { if (!options || options.length === 0) { // This case implies an issue with how options are passed or an empty configuration. // Returning undefined is safer than the original's options[0] which would error. return undefined; } var eligibleOptions = []; var totalPositiveWeight = 0; // First pass: Collect options with strictly positive weights and sum these weights. for (var i = 0; i < options.length; i++) { var option = options[i]; // Ensure weight is treated as a number; default undefined/non-numeric to 0. var weight = (typeof option.weight === 'number') ? option.weight : 0; if (weight > 0) { eligibleOptions.push(option); totalPositiveWeight += weight; } } if (totalPositiveWeight > 0) { // If there are options with positive weights, choose from them. var randomValue = Math.random() * totalPositiveWeight; var cumulativeWeight = 0; for (var j = 0; j < eligibleOptions.length; j++) { // eligibleOptions[j].weight is guaranteed to be > 0 here. cumulativeWeight += eligibleOptions[j].weight; if (randomValue <= cumulativeWeight) { return eligibleOptions[j]; } } // Fallback for rare floating-point precision issues or if randomValue is exactly totalPositiveWeight. // Returning the last eligible option is a robust choice here. return eligibleOptions[eligibleOptions.length - 1]; } else { // No options with positive weight were found. // This means all original options had weights <= 0 (e.g., all zeros or empty list of positive weights). // In this scenario, pick one randomly from the original 'options' list, // giving all of them an equal chance. return options[Math.floor(Math.random() * options.length)]; } } // Initialize all remaining AdSense ads $("ins.adsbygoogle").each(function() { $("(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({})").insertAfter($(this)); }); var js = document.createElement("script"); js.type = "text/javascript"; js.async = true; js.src = "https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"; document.body.appendChild(js); } }); });
Back
Top