Great job, nice pictures! Sounds like you left PM in the dust and brewed all grain with an amazing extraction for your first batch!
As for the LME, maybe you know some friends / family who need to start brewing?
At your request, I checked the recipe and brew session data:
The recipe has an estimated 50% efficiency, with an OG of 1.032. You beat that, and looks like you hit closer to 70% efficiency, which is good. The volumes don't line up though (5.5 gallons recipe vs 4.75 gallons actual), which would contribute to a higher gravity in the real beer. Water volume management is the next thing to dial in. There are settings under your equipment profile. It normally takes a couple brews on new equipment to get it down pat. This post details that subject:
http://www.brewersfriend.com/2010/06/12 ... n-brewing/
By the way,what size carboy is that? It looks like a 5 gallon to me, but I can't tell what the unit is for the marks.
In terms of the brew session, the only number that looks off is Brew House Efficiency. It should be below ending kettle efficiency. For boil complete, it shows a gravity of 1.051, but then for brew day complete it lists 1.065. Those two gravities should be the same.
Also, not sure how the mash complete and pre-boil gravity were taken, but at pre-boil it added only 0.15 gallons, but got a gravity decrease from 1.065 to 1.060. Make sure the hydrometer readings are temperature corrected.
This FAQ has more information on what the system is expecting to see in terms of log events tied to efficiency calculations:
http://www.brewersfriend.com/faq/#brewsessions5